Welcome to Post Office Cafe
Post Office Cafe in Babylon, NY offers a cozy atmosphere with a diverse menu ranging from handhelds like Monterey Chicken Club to hearty soups and salads. The burger selection, including the Truffle Shroom Burger, is a standout with its unique flavors. Customers appreciate the attentive service, with mentions of server CJ going above and beyond. The food, like the Buddha bowl with added shrimp, receives high praise for its delicious flavors. Despite some mixed reviews on service speed, the overall experience at Post Office Cafe is recommended for those looking for a casual dining spot with good food and a friendly ambiance.
-
130 W Main St Babylon, NY 11702130 W Main St Babylon, NY 11702 Hotline: (631) 669-9224
Welcome to Post Office Cafe, a unique dining experience nestled in the charming heart of Babylon, NY. This American cocktail bar offers a delightful blend of delectable dishes and an inviting atmosphere that promises to elevate your dining adventures. Conveniently located at 130 W Main St, this establishment is a must-visit for food lovers and cocktail enthusiasts alike.
At Post Office Cafe, the menu is a celebration of bold flavors and creative combinations. Highlights include the Blackened Salmon Bowl, where charred cauliflower meets a vibrant mix of baby kale, quinoa, and a creamy lemon vinaigrette, providing an explosion of textures and tastes. For those craving a heartier option, the Root Beer Braised Short Rib served with Yukon whipped potatoes and seasonal vegetables is a standout choice, leaving a lasting impression of rich, savory goodness.
The atmosphere here is casual yet stylish, making it a perfect spot for everything from a family outing to a night out with friends. On busier evenings, the service can occasionally have its quirks, as noted by several patrons. However, many guests have praised the attentiveness and expertise of the staff, especially during larger gatherings, with servers like CJ and Alice earning commendations for their excellent service.
While some diners have experienced minor service hiccups - such as delayed menus or pesky flies - the overall experience tends to be overshadowed by the exceptional quality of the food. Customers have particularly raved about the Spring Chicken Rolls, describing them as "divine" and an absolute must-try.
Whether you’re stopping by for a post-show bite or a leisurely dinner with friends, Post Office Cafe is a culinary destination that’s sure to satisfy. Don't forget to indulge in their signature desserts to round off your meal; it’s the perfect way to conclude an impressive dining experience.
In essence, Post Office Cafe embodies what it means to enjoy quality American cuisine in a laid-back yet elegant setting. As you plan your visit, prepare to immerse yourself in their vibrant flavors and warm hospitality—it's an experience that will surely leave a delectable mark on your culinary memory.
Service was great. Alice was our server. She was attentive to our large group and handled everything expertly. Everyone seemed to like their food. I ordered the Classic American Burger. It was cooked perfectly Medium Rare. Could have used a pinch of salt. I wish I remembered to ask if it was char grilled. Blech. I would have ordered something else. That's on me though. I would recommend if catching a show a Argyle. Nice menu with a lot of options from which to choose. All around a good choice. Was it the most amazing meal? No but it was very good. Forgot to take a photo of my burger.
Post Office Cafe delivered! Okay, puns aside, the food here is absolutely delicious! This place has a very nice ambiance. I went on a quiet Monday evening with friends. Service was friendly but could have been stepped up a notch. It took us a while to receive menus. Another downside were the nats/flies that were inside and were bothersome. Definitely if you are ordering appetizers go for the spring chicken rolls (so divine!).
The food was delicious. I got the Buddha bowl and added shrimp. It was a Monday evening and the service was terrible. I'm hoping it was just a bad night but it wasn't busy. I felt totally ignored. But the ambiance is very nice, large bar. I'd go back because the food is so good. Hopefully that was just one bad night.
CJ was great. We had a group of 25+ and he stayed on top of everything. Thank you. P.s. dessert was wonderful.
Cj was an amazing server and treated my big family and I so well with much patience, thank you Cj
CJ rocked! Service was amazing, and CJ was incredibly kind. Food was good. Ambiance was accommodating to our needs
I came here with a friend for a late lunch/early dinner. We decided on sharing two appetizers; spinach artichoke dip and boneless wings; chipotle bbq flavor. Both were very good! The spinach dip came with pita bread and chips for dipping. It was ooey gooey cheesey good! The boneless wings were good too and had a nice flavor. Both were a great size for both of us to share and munch on. Service was good. We said we would come back and try more of the menu!